Software Development and Movie Making

Way back in early 90’s, my brother and I were having a conversation around the theme as to how software development was more closer to making a movie. For some reason, this conversation stayed in my mind and I distinctly remember that it was right after a TV show featuring Subhash Ghai where he talked about different aspects of movie making. 

Mats Wessberg writing in Developerworks @ IBM uses the same analogy in his article "Introducing the IBM Rational Unified process by Analogy", where he talks of "How is software development like moviemaking"

Making a feature film is a vast undertaking that involves managing a
huge crew and a substantial budget. Communicating well about needed
changes is vital to the success of such a project. Imagine that the
director wants to improve the final scene. Although it comes at the end
of the movie, the need for improvement can be identified early since
quality is continuously verified on all levels. Do the screenwriters
have to update the script? Who will review and approve it? Does the
scene have to be modeled again? If so, will storyboards, 3D graphics,
or plastic models be used? Does the set need to be modified, or does a
new set need to be built? Do we have to scout for a new location? Do we
need to call the special effects guys? How does this affect our budget?
Do we have to ask for more time and money? These are the kinds of
questions that result in changing plans and therefore must be
addressed, preferably in an iterative manner.

But the analogy that I liked the best:

If the functional requirements of software have their counterpart in
movies, can a movie also have nonfunctional requirements? The answer
(not surprisingly) is yes. Maybe (for commercial reasons) the movie
must be viewable by children under 18 and no longer than 120 minutes.
Although these requirements aren’t directly related to the story line,
they’ll have an impact on the final result — just as nonfunctional
software requirements must have on a computer system.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Software Development and Movie Making

  1. The one big diff is that after go-live if there are any problems, s/w guys get a chance to backout and fix the problem. in case of movies, once it has hit the theater if it fails there is no way u get that second chance for that movie.

  2. Good analogy. However a s/w that fails in User Acceptance test meets the same fate as that of a failed movie except I guess if it is a M/S product 😉

    Interestingly, there was this Amitabh’ movie – Agnipath -where they redubbed the film and re-released it since the audience rejected the original voice recording of Amitabh and wanted his baritone voice back.

    And as I recollect it went onto become a hit.

    Raj

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s